Haven’t been able to plough through his 300 pages, but based on what’s been reported, what can we expect ‘after Milburn’ (There’ll be a government White Paper early next year).
In sharp contrast to the Tories crude ‘cut welfare’ agenda and in the context of Milburn’s arguments that by themselves benefit cuts ‘won’t work’, Labour leaders will want to be seen to be playing things very differently. They’ll hope that rebellious back- benchers will buy a package focusing on ‘job support’ with benefit cuts only for those who refuse, (those unable to work will, it’s claimed ‘get more’ ).
They’ll certainly be wary of how the new ‘youth allowance’ will replace existing benefits and even more so about plans to include those with ‘milder’ mental health conditions, but now be expected to be part of Milburn’s new Working State rather be ‘dependent’ on the (old?) Welfare State.
If we aren’t going to doubt Andy Burnham’s ‘moral’ commitment to drastically reducing the number of NEETs, or that of a ‘changed’ (from his Blairite days at least) Milburn, the main question is whether his proposals are going to work. If the are not significant reductions in the NEET rate – Milburn wants it to half by the end of the decade – what will happen to benefit payments then?
Though some of the bigger players will welcome the PR opportunities gained from being seem to be helping unemployed youngsters develop ‘workplace skills’, for the most part Burnham and his close collaborator Pat McFadden are relying on predominently private sector employers to turn ‘job support’ into ‘job creation’. In this respect they are seeking to buck historical trends without spending the billions that even Milburn thinks will be necessary (but could work out at far more, 6 month subsidised employment doesn’t come cheap).
Youth joblessness (around half of NEETs are officially unemployed rather than sick – arguably many more would be enjoying better mental health if they could find employment) has been much higher than general unemployment for many years. It’s been intensified by the financial crash and Covid, but these are not the cause of it – neither are current increases in employer national insurance. Forecasts predict it will go much higher.
Though Milburn focuses on the NEETs, the crisis in youth employment is much broader. The post -war ‘youth jobs’ are no longer around, with apprenticeships for school leavers almost nonexistent as industrial jobs have given way to low-paid service sector employment. Those who are able, have delayed their transition to the labour market, have flocked to university in the absence of any other clear alternative.
Though Blair’s goal of half of all young people going to university has been met, for many, work no longer pays in the way it once did, and – despite the rising price of obtaining one – neither does a degree. While graduate unemployment might remain relatively low, as significant as the NEETs are the ‘GINGEs’ – ‘graduates in non-graduate employment’ – with surveys showing up to 30% in this category 18 months after leaving university.
This downsizing of expectations not only leads to frustration and increased anxiety, but also, as more jobs become ‘graduatised’, pushes those less qualified further down the labour queue – or pushed out of it completely. Now, there’s increasing evidence that the uncertainties around AI are leading to further reductions in ‘entry-level’ employment.
A 25 year old, three years out of university, but working in a bar, living in the parental home with a huge student debt is just as much a part of the crisis as a 17 year old who’s slipped through the education safety net but never worked. Young people also face high levels of labour market ‘churning’ – having to move from job to job interspersed with periods of unemployment (and temporarily becoming NEET)
While horrendous examples of young people being let down should not be ignored, NEETs have been stereotyped as educational failures. Schools and their partner agencies will continue to take the blame, with Burnham’s call for yet another round of new technical qualifications resonating with some. But up to a quarter of NEETs have remained in education to Advanced level while approaching 1 in 6 have degrees).
The debate needs to move on to ask more searching questions about the direction major changes to labour market recruitment should take and much more significantly, what sort of future economy will be able to deliver these. It will need to move well beyond just replacing job centres with ‘job hubs’ to wider issues around economic planning, a dramatically increased role for the public sector and how Milburn’s ‘new deal’ for young people can be a central part of a new Green New Deal in general. More on all this later…..

Thanks Martin. As ever a clear analysis of what I think will be a further club to beat young people Sent from my iPhoneOn 18 Nov 2026,