(Not) going on a summer holiday?

Once again, Michael Gove is posing as the ‘moderniser’ .  He now wants to persuade us that we need to bring the length of  school  holidays in line with those in Asian Pacific economies like Singapore and Hong Kong. So as to ‘raise standard.stock-illustration-16627093-summer-holiday-children-holding-hands-cartoon-illustration

As argued in The Great Reversal,   Gove’s   attempt to cherry pick policies from elsewhere is highly selective and a little dishonest.   For example, high performing, but league table free Finland, a country that  after featuring in earlier policy statements has been gradually dropped as a blue print for reform,   has 11-week summer breaks.  Students and teachers  in neighbouring Sweden struggle along with just ten!

Most teachers would also welcome the relaxed atmosphere of Finland’s classrooms rather than the rote learning and fact regurgitation, not to mention the stress and parental obsession that is associated with school systems in many Asian Pacific countries.

There are many other reasons for the high growth rates in the Asian Pacific economies that have little to do with their education programmes – including differences in wage levels, employment laws and labour rights  for example.  In fact there is no conclusive evidence about what sort of education systems produce the most economic growth and development.

Getting back to the issue of holidays. Independent schools in England and Wales, which have longer summer holidays certainly don’t  feel the need to reduce them or increase  their hours for that matter,  while at Oxford and Cambridge universities, students attend for less than half the year. There’s a debate to be had about whether all school terms should be the same length and on how school buildings can be made more available for community activity during school holidays. But on this one,   Gove really takes the biscuit.

Martin Allen

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s